If you’re looking for delicious pizza and authentic Italian food, then you’ll love Palermo Pizzeria. Serving lunch and dinner, we cater to everyone’s tastes in our casual and relaxing family-friendly atmosphere. We’re locally owned and operated by owners Lori Mattingly and Vincent Mattone.
Whatever you’re craving, we’ve got it.
Whether you’re craving freshly-made pizza, specialty pasta, salads, or a delicious hero sandwich, we’ve got it all. We have a pizzeria side and a upscale dining room side, so you can choose to sit where you’d like. You’ll love our daily specials and homemade desserts too!
Looking for great food to go?
You can get our take-out service or have us deliver food to you as well. This is available for all menu items.
Planning an event?
You want your event to go as smoothly as possible. When you choose Palermo Pizzeria for all of your catering needs, you won’t have to worry about a thing. Choose from our menu items or create your own custom menu. Choose from on-site or off-site catering.
Featuring Our Staff:
Chef Danni - formerly of the Food Network. Worked with some great chefs including Bobby Flay, Emeril, Guy Fidretti, the Nally’s and was the pizza guy for the original Palermo in Seaford.
Vinnie Mattone – the chef / owner of Butlers Quarters in Hempstead, Vinnie’s Place and Yankee Doodle in Manhattan.
Lori Mattingly – Ex-model turned restaurant manager in Manhattan managing The Amazon Club, Via Via and more.
We are proud to bring you the “Best Pizza in the Area” voted by the people who count, our customers. In our newly designed dining room we feature Italian classics and more prepared fresh to order. Even our salad dressings and desserts are homemade.
Delicious, authentic Italian food that will have you coming back
You’ll love our Italian dishes and pizza. Call 516-731-3700 or visit 1495 Hicksville Road for our daily specials.